Episode 20  ·  12m 45s

Is My Dog Too Old for Anesthesia? More Pet Parent FAQs, Part 2

Dr. Michael LoSasso, DVM & Julie Schwenzer Frisco Emergency Pet Care
Lumps and bumps Anesthesia safety Senior pets Chocolate toxicity Foreign objects Training
"Pet parents ask some of the best, and sometimes the most urgent, questions. Today we're digging into the ones that can truly make a difference in your pet's health and safety."
— Julie Schwenzer

Episode summary

Part two of the pet-parent FAQ series covers the questions that came up next: lumps, senior anesthesia risk, and which foods are actually dangerous versus overhyped. Dr. LoSasso's honest answer on lumps is that every new one should technically be checked, though experience lets him recognize some on sight — sebaceous adenomas in older Poodles and Schnauzers, or lipomas (fatty masses), are usually benign. He admits he personally sits on the fence about removing small lipomas early, since waiting can mean the mass grows large enough that removal becomes a much bigger project later — he's seen basketball-sized lipomas on not-very-large dogs. For anything less obviously benign, a fine-needle aspirate and cytology review — often assisted by AI alongside a cytologist or clinical pathologist — helps decide whether removal is warranted.

The bigger myth he wants to correct is around senior pets and anesthesia. He hears constantly from owners whose own vet told them a 12-year-old dog is "too old" for a dental cleaning or mass removal — and he pushes back hard on that framing.

"Those are the same drugs they used on the Queen Mother when she was 98 years old, and they replaced both of her hips. If those drugs are good enough for the most beloved person ever to live in the United Kingdom to have surgery at close to 100 years of age, I don't think it's really that dangerous."
— Dr. Michael LoSasso, DVM

He puts real numbers on it: anesthesia complications occur less than 0.1% of the time in young, healthy dogs. Older, higher-risk dogs may carry five to ten times that risk — which sounds alarming until you do the math and land at roughly 0.5% to 1%. Modern hospitals pair anesthesia with constant ECG and end-tidal CO2 monitoring, technology that's become smaller and cheaper over the years. His actual position: dental disease left untreated is often more dangerous than the anesthesia used to treat it. His practical advice — combine procedures into a single anesthetic episode when possible (a mass removal alongside a dental cleaning, for example) so a pet isn't put under more often than necessary.

What's actually dangerous to eat — and what isn't

Unrisen yeast bread dough is genuinely dangerous and warrants an ER visit every time — the dough keeps expanding in the warmth of the stomach. Chocolate risk scales with the dog's size, the amount eaten, and the cocoa percentage: white chocolate has no caffeine and isn't toxic, milk chocolate has a little, semi-sweet more, and dark gourmet chocolates (64-84% cocoa) carry the most. Cookies containing chocolate are usually low risk since they rarely use enough dark chocolate to matter — macadamia nuts are the exception to watch for. Raw meat is generally low risk both for infection and as a foreign body. Any human medication, though, should always be treated seriously — the dosing math is too unpredictable to guess at home.

On whether a passed object means everything's fine: generally yes — if it makes it all the way through, it's typically no longer a problem. But Dr. LoSasso cautions that a dog who's "gotten away with it" repeatedly has just been dodging real risk each time, not proving it's always safe. He also weighed in on obedience training: it strengthens the bond between dog and owner and makes handling easier, but he hasn't seen it meaningfully reduce counter-surfing or foreign-body ingestion — even well-trained dogs will counter surf given the chance, especially taller breeds like doodles.

Questions answered in this episode

The following questions are answered by Dr. LoSasso in this episode, drawn directly from the conversation. These are real clinical answers from a practicing emergency veterinarian with 30+ years of experience.

Dr. LoSasso says the honest answer is that every new lump should be checked out, at least for peace of mind. With experience, some are recognizable as benign on sight — sebaceous adenomas in older poodles and Schnauzers, for instance, or lipomas (fatty masses), which are common and usually harmless unless they grow large enough to impede function. For anything less obviously benign, he recommends a fine-needle aspirate and cytology, often reviewed with AI assistance or a cytologist/clinical pathologist, to help decide whether it needs to come off.
Dr. LoSasso pushes back on this directly, saying his view differs from a lot of conventional wisdom pet owners still hear. Modern anesthesia — typically propofol or alfaxalone combined with sevoflurane or isoflurane, with ECG and end-tidal CO2 monitoring — is the same class of drugs used on elderly human patients for major surgery. He estimates complication rates under 0.1% in young healthy dogs, rising to roughly 0.5-1% in higher-risk older dogs — a real increase, but still low. His view: dental disease is often more dangerous than modern anesthesia.
Yes, when feasible. Dr. LoSasso recommends combining procedures — for example, a mass removal and a dental cleaning — into a single anesthetic event rather than doing them separately, so the pet isn't put under more often than necessary. He notes it's typically the more cost-effective approach as well.
It depends on the dog's size, the amount eaten, and the cocoa concentration. Dr. LoSasso explains white chocolate has essentially no caffeine and isn't toxic, milk chocolate has a bit more, semi-sweet more still, and darker gourmet chocolates (64%, 72%, 84% cocoa) carry the most caffeine and are the most dangerous. Cookies containing chocolate are usually low-risk since they rarely use enough of the dangerous dark chocolate to matter — the exception is cookies with substantial macadamia nuts, which are a separate hazard.
Dr. LoSasso says unrisen yeast bread dough is incredibly dangerous and warrants an ER visit every single time — the yeast continues to expand in the warm, moist environment of the stomach. Raw meat, by contrast, is usually low risk both for infection and as a foreign body. Any human medication ingestion should also be treated seriously and evaluated immediately, since dosing risk varies too much by drug and by the dog's size to guess at home.
Generally yes — if an object makes it all the way through and comes out the other end, it's typically no longer a problem. Dr. LoSasso cautions, though, that a dog who has "gotten lucky" passing objects before has just been dodging a real risk each time, not proving it's always safe; partial obstruction is what turns dangerous.
JuliePet parents ask some of the best, and sometimes the most urgent, questions. Today we're digging into the ones that can truly make a difference in your pet's health and safety. This is part two of parent-frequently-asked-questions — last time you covered vaccines, diet, when a dog swallows something it shouldn't, and dental care. Today, can we start with lumps? When do you think a lump could be dangerous and needs to be checked, versus cases where it's just benign, like a fatty mass?
Dr. LoSassoGood question. I think the right answer is probably every one should be checked out. But those of us with years of experience, dealing with a 12-year-old Poodle, know that those little raised, fleshy-colored masses we see on Poodles, Schnauzers, and other older dogs are usually benign — sebaceous adenomas. Removal isn't a big deal; they actually interfere with the groomer more than anything else, tending to bleed and ooze if clippers run over them. We also see quite a few fatty masses, lipomas — they occur in people and dogs, occasionally cats. Those benign fatty masses sometimes catch up to us: a lot of us won't remove them unless they're impeding function, and then we get stuck in a catch-22 — too small to be worth the time, and then a couple years later it's grown too big to be a small project. I've seen basketball-sized lipomas on not-very-large dogs. Almost everything else, though, I'd recommend checking out — at least a cytology study, a fine needle aspirate, putting a small needle in and checking the cells, using AI as well as having a cytologist or clinical pathologist give an opinion. I personally probably have more lipomas than any dog you know — it happens in people too, and it took me forever to have one of mine looked at, probably 20 years. We don't have that kind of time to wait with pets. Everything really should be looked at, if nothing else, for your peace of mind.
JulieThat makes me think of senior dogs who encounter this more often as they age — is my dog too old to operate on? Is that too risky? Is that a concern you weigh a lot — whether to put an older dog through anesthesia and the healing process?
Dr. LoSassoMy opinion differs quite a bit from a lot of conventional wisdom I still hear day to day. I get a lot of people telling me their dog is 12 and their doctor said she's too old to have her teeth cleaned. I'd point out that most modern hospitals, including ours, use a combination of propofol or alfaxalone with sevoflurane or isoflurane — some form of inhalant to keep them anesthetized. Those are the same drugs used on the Queen Mother when she was 98 and they replaced both her hips. If those drugs are good enough for the most beloved person in the United Kingdom to have surgery at close to 100, I don't think it's really that dangerous. I'd suggest dental disease is actually more dangerous than anesthesia. Yes, you're at increased risk — age isn't a disease, but it carries changes in the body, and I understand that better now that I'm almost 60 than I did 20 years ago. I'd even say the chance of an untoward anesthesia reaction might be five to ten times higher in an older dog — which sounds terrifying until you do the math on the original percentage. The incidence of problems under anesthesia in young healthy dogs is less than one in a thousand, or 0.1%. Multiply that by five or ten and you're looking at half a percent to one percent. We'd like that closer to zero, but modern hospitals run constant ECG monitoring, often end-tidal CO2 — monitoring technology has gotten better, smaller, and cheaper across the board, so it's become routine in small animal practice. Anesthesia is safe. I'd still have that mass removed. We do want to take advantage of every anesthetic episode though — if we've got a mass to remove and know we're doing a teeth cleaning, it makes sense to do the workup and everything at once, so you're not putting them under more often than necessary. Common sense, and usually the cheaper way to do it too.
JulieAnother question — how much warrants a trip to the ER, and what doesn't, when it comes to chocolate, and things they might grab off the counter, cookies or raw meat?
Dr. LoSassoRaw meat probably isn't usually a big deal — from an infectious disease standpoint that's pretty negligible, and as a foreign body, pretty negligible too. Unrisen bread dough containing yeast is incredibly dangerous and warrants a trip to the ER every time. Cookies almost never — they'd need a ton of macadamia nuts or a ton of really dark chocolate, and people typically don't use the expensive, most toxic chocolate in cookies. So it isn't nearly as dangerous as you might think. Straight chocolate depends on the size of the dog, the amount, and the type. White chocolate has no caffeine, not toxic at all. Milk chocolate has a bit more. Semi-sweet has more. Then the more expensive forms — 64%, 72%, 84% cocoa — as the percentage goes up, so does the caffeine, and that's the dangerous part. With human medication, I'd be concerned about all of it — you just don't know the dose, it depends on the size of the dog and a lot of other things. We almost invariably prefer to have it out rather than in.
JulieOn that note — if the dog gets it all out, whether they throw it up or it passes the other way, like a whole bag of jelly beans that came out intact — are we safe, or is there a chance something got into the body or other systems?
Dr. LoSassoTypically, if it passes all the way through, it's fine. I've had clients say "I can't believe that sock got stuck, we find a sock in the backyard once a month" — and I'm thinking, well, you've been dodging a lot of bullets, this is just the one you didn't get away with. It certainly can be a problem, but if it makes it all the way out, typically it's not an issue.
JulieYou're clearly an advocate for training and avoiding behavioral issues — do you see a real difference, like dogs trained not to pull on the leash or take things off the counter avoiding these other emergencies?
Dr. LoSassoI don't know that I've seen a lot of difference in foreign body ingestion or counter surfing between dogs with a lot of obedience work and those without. The bond with their owner is much stronger, because obedience training is as much for the human as it is for the dog — it helps you stay on the same page, understand how they think, and they get to understand your mannerisms. It certainly makes walking them easier, which means it probably happens more often, which is good. But even the well-behaved ones, I suspect, would still counter surf if they had the opportunity. It's not really a problem in a Dachshund, but it is in the taller dogs, the doodles, and others.

Related guides

Related services

Have a question for Dr. LoSasso?

We are open right now — and if your pet needs emergency care, come straight in.